William Calvin
(1939-)
William H. Calvin is a professor emeritus of neurophysiology at the University of Washington in Seattle. He studies neuroscience and evolutionary biology following the ideas of neural Darwinism, the biological, and more specifically Darwinian and selectionist, approach to understanding global brain function.
Neural Darwinism was first proposed by American biologist and Nobel-Prize recipient
Gerald Edelman in his 1987 book of the same name
Neural Darwinism – The Theory of Neuronal Group Selection.
But Neural Darwinism theory goes back to Edelman and
Vernon Mountcastle's 1978 book,
The Mindful Brain – Cortical Organization and the Group-selective Theory of Higher Brain Function, which describes the columnar structure of the cortical groups within the neocortex. Mountcastle described them as "minicolumns."
Calvin visualizes the cortical minicolumns as patterns which he calls the "cerebral codes."
Calvin describes patterns in the minicolumns as a representation of the words in our vocabulary.
In particular, we need to know about the cerebral codes those
patterns that represent each of the words of our vocabulary,
and so forth - and what creates them. At first, it appears
that we are dealing with a four-dimensional pattern - the
active neurons scattered through three-dimensional cortex, as
they perform in time. But largely because the minicolumns
seem to organize all the cortical layer around similar interests,
most people working on cortex think of it as a two-dimensional
sheet rather like the retina (yes, the retina is 0.3
mm thick and is subdivided into a few layers, but the mapping
is clearly for a two-dimensional image).
So we can try thinking of two dimensions, plus time, for
cortex [which is, of course, the way we apprehend the images
on a movie screen or computur terrninal] -perhaps with transparent
overlays when the different cortical layers do different
things. Just imagine the human cortex flattened out on those
four sheets of typing paper like pie crust. with little patches
lighting up like message-board pixels. What patterns will we
observe when that cortex is seeing a comb? When the word
"comb" is heard, or said? When the cortex is commanding a
hand to comb the hair?
When Calvin describes memory as resembling the firing sequence at input to memory, i.e., in a "Hebbian assembly," he is close to our
ERR model of the mind. But we do not see the neurons as a "representation of words," as he does.
Memory recall may consist of
the creation of a spatiotemporal
sequence of neuron firings - probably a sequence similar
to the firing sequence at the time of the input to memory. but
shorn of some of the nonessential frills that promoted it. The
recalled spatioternporal pattern would be something like a
message board in a stadium, with lots of little lights flashing
on and off, creating an overall pallern. A somewhar more general
version of such a Hebbian cell assembly would avoid
anchoring the spatiotemporal pattern to particular cells, to
make it more like the way the message board can scroll. The
pattern continues to mean the same thing, even when it's
implemented by different lights.
How Brains Work, p.121
Calvin's Major Transitions
Calvin proposed his own "major transitions" as a modified version of those by
John Maynard-Smith and
Eörs Szathmáry.
Normal |
Teacher |
Scholar