Citation for this page in APA citation style.           Close


Philosophers

Mortimer Adler
Rogers Albritton
Alexander of Aphrodisias
Samuel Alexander
William Alston
Anaximander
G.E.M.Anscombe
Anselm
Louise Antony
Thomas Aquinas
Aristotle
David Armstrong
Harald Atmanspacher
Robert Audi
Augustine
J.L.Austin
A.J.Ayer
Alexander Bain
Mark Balaguer
Jeffrey Barrett
William Barrett
William Belsham
Henri Bergson
George Berkeley
Isaiah Berlin
Richard J. Bernstein
Bernard Berofsky
Robert Bishop
Max Black
Susanne Bobzien
Emil du Bois-Reymond
Hilary Bok
Laurence BonJour
George Boole
Émile Boutroux
Daniel Boyd
F.H.Bradley
C.D.Broad
Michael Burke
Lawrence Cahoone
C.A.Campbell
Joseph Keim Campbell
Rudolf Carnap
Carneades
Nancy Cartwright
Gregg Caruso
Ernst Cassirer
David Chalmers
Roderick Chisholm
Chrysippus
Cicero
Randolph Clarke
Samuel Clarke
Anthony Collins
Antonella Corradini
Diodorus Cronus
Jonathan Dancy
Donald Davidson
Mario De Caro
Democritus
Daniel Dennett
Jacques Derrida
René Descartes
Richard Double
Fred Dretske
John Dupré
John Earman
Laura Waddell Ekstrom
Epictetus
Epicurus
Austin Farrer
Herbert Feigl
Arthur Fine
John Martin Fischer
Frederic Fitch
Owen Flanagan
Luciano Floridi
Philippa Foot
Alfred Fouilleé
Harry Frankfurt
Richard L. Franklin
Bas van Fraassen
Michael Frede
Gottlob Frege
Peter Geach
Edmund Gettier
Carl Ginet
Alvin Goldman
Gorgias
Nicholas St. John Green
H.Paul Grice
Ian Hacking
Ishtiyaque Haji
Stuart Hampshire
W.F.R.Hardie
Sam Harris
William Hasker
R.M.Hare
Georg W.F. Hegel
Martin Heidegger
Heraclitus
R.E.Hobart
Thomas Hobbes
David Hodgson
Shadsworth Hodgson
Baron d'Holbach
Ted Honderich
Pamela Huby
David Hume
Ferenc Huoranszki
Frank Jackson
William James
Lord Kames
Robert Kane
Immanuel Kant
Tomis Kapitan
Walter Kaufmann
Jaegwon Kim
William King
Hilary Kornblith
Christine Korsgaard
Saul Kripke
Thomas Kuhn
Andrea Lavazza
Christoph Lehner
Keith Lehrer
Gottfried Leibniz
Jules Lequyer
Leucippus
Michael Levin
Joseph Levine
George Henry Lewes
C.I.Lewis
David Lewis
Peter Lipton
C. Lloyd Morgan
John Locke
Michael Lockwood
Arthur O. Lovejoy
E. Jonathan Lowe
John R. Lucas
Lucretius
Alasdair MacIntyre
Ruth Barcan Marcus
Tim Maudlin
James Martineau
Nicholas Maxwell
Storrs McCall
Hugh McCann
Colin McGinn
Michael McKenna
Brian McLaughlin
John McTaggart
Paul E. Meehl
Uwe Meixner
Alfred Mele
Trenton Merricks
John Stuart Mill
Dickinson Miller
G.E.Moore
Thomas Nagel
Otto Neurath
Friedrich Nietzsche
John Norton
P.H.Nowell-Smith
Robert Nozick
William of Ockham
Timothy O'Connor
Parmenides
David F. Pears
Charles Sanders Peirce
Derk Pereboom
Steven Pinker
Plato
Karl Popper
Porphyry
Huw Price
H.A.Prichard
Protagoras
Hilary Putnam
Willard van Orman Quine
Frank Ramsey
Ayn Rand
Michael Rea
Thomas Reid
Charles Renouvier
Nicholas Rescher
C.W.Rietdijk
Richard Rorty
Josiah Royce
Bertrand Russell
Paul Russell
Gilbert Ryle
Jean-Paul Sartre
Kenneth Sayre
T.M.Scanlon
Moritz Schlick
Arthur Schopenhauer
John Searle
Wilfrid Sellars
Alan Sidelle
Ted Sider
Henry Sidgwick
Walter Sinnott-Armstrong
J.J.C.Smart
Saul Smilansky
Michael Smith
Baruch Spinoza
L. Susan Stebbing
Isabelle Stengers
George F. Stout
Galen Strawson
Peter Strawson
Eleonore Stump
Francisco Suárez
Richard Taylor
Kevin Timpe
Mark Twain
Peter Unger
Peter van Inwagen
Manuel Vargas
John Venn
Kadri Vihvelin
Voltaire
G.H. von Wright
David Foster Wallace
R. Jay Wallace
W.G.Ward
Ted Warfield
Roy Weatherford
C.F. von Weizsäcker
William Whewell
Alfred North Whitehead
David Widerker
David Wiggins
Bernard Williams
Timothy Williamson
Ludwig Wittgenstein
Susan Wolf

Scientists

David Albert
Michael Arbib
Walter Baade
Bernard Baars
Jeffrey Bada
Leslie Ballentine
Marcello Barbieri
Gregory Bateson
Horace Barlow
John S. Bell
Mara Beller
Charles Bennett
Ludwig von Bertalanffy
Susan Blackmore
Margaret Boden
David Bohm
Niels Bohr
Ludwig Boltzmann
Emile Borel
Max Born
Satyendra Nath Bose
Walther Bothe
Jean Bricmont
Hans Briegel
Leon Brillouin
Stephen Brush
Henry Thomas Buckle
S. H. Burbury
Melvin Calvin
Donald Campbell
Sadi Carnot
Anthony Cashmore
Eric Chaisson
Gregory Chaitin
Jean-Pierre Changeux
Rudolf Clausius
Arthur Holly Compton
John Conway
Jerry Coyne
John Cramer
Francis Crick
E. P. Culverwell
Antonio Damasio
Olivier Darrigol
Charles Darwin
Richard Dawkins
Terrence Deacon
Lüder Deecke
Richard Dedekind
Louis de Broglie
Stanislas Dehaene
Max Delbrück
Abraham de Moivre
Bernard d'Espagnat
Paul Dirac
Hans Driesch
John Eccles
Arthur Stanley Eddington
Gerald Edelman
Paul Ehrenfest
Manfred Eigen
Albert Einstein
George F. R. Ellis
Hugh Everett, III
Franz Exner
Richard Feynman
R. A. Fisher
David Foster
Joseph Fourier
Philipp Frank
Steven Frautschi
Edward Fredkin
Benjamin Gal-Or
Howard Gardner
Lila Gatlin
Michael Gazzaniga
Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen
GianCarlo Ghirardi
J. Willard Gibbs
James J. Gibson
Nicolas Gisin
Paul Glimcher
Thomas Gold
A. O. Gomes
Brian Goodwin
Joshua Greene
Dirk ter Haar
Jacques Hadamard
Mark Hadley
Patrick Haggard
J. B. S. Haldane
Stuart Hameroff
Augustin Hamon
Sam Harris
Ralph Hartley
Hyman Hartman
Jeff Hawkins
John-Dylan Haynes
Donald Hebb
Martin Heisenberg
Werner Heisenberg
John Herschel
Basil Hiley
Art Hobson
Jesper Hoffmeyer
Don Howard
John H. Jackson
William Stanley Jevons
Roman Jakobson
E. T. Jaynes
Pascual Jordan
Eric Kandel
Ruth E. Kastner
Stuart Kauffman
Martin J. Klein
William R. Klemm
Christof Koch
Simon Kochen
Hans Kornhuber
Stephen Kosslyn
Daniel Koshland
Ladislav Kovàč
Leopold Kronecker
Rolf Landauer
Alfred Landé
Pierre-Simon Laplace
Karl Lashley
David Layzer
Joseph LeDoux
Gerald Lettvin
Gilbert Lewis
Benjamin Libet
David Lindley
Seth Lloyd
Hendrik Lorentz
Werner Loewenstein
Josef Loschmidt
Ernst Mach
Donald MacKay
Henry Margenau
Owen Maroney
David Marr
Humberto Maturana
James Clerk Maxwell
Ernst Mayr
John McCarthy
Warren McCulloch
N. David Mermin
George Miller
Stanley Miller
Ulrich Mohrhoff
Jacques Monod
Vernon Mountcastle
Emmy Noether
Donald Norman
Alexander Oparin
Abraham Pais
Howard Pattee
Wolfgang Pauli
Massimo Pauri
Wilder Penfield
Roger Penrose
Steven Pinker
Colin Pittendrigh
Walter Pitts
Max Planck
Susan Pockett
Henri Poincaré
Daniel Pollen
Ilya Prigogine
Hans Primas
Zenon Pylyshyn
Henry Quastler
Adolphe Quételet
Pasco Rakic
Nicolas Rashevsky
Lord Rayleigh
Frederick Reif
Jürgen Renn
Giacomo Rizzolati
Emil Roduner
Juan Roederer
Jerome Rothstein
David Ruelle
David Rumelhart
Tilman Sauer
Ferdinand de Saussure
Jürgen Schmidhuber
Erwin Schrödinger
Aaron Schurger
Sebastian Seung
Thomas Sebeok
Franco Selleri
Claude Shannon
Charles Sherrington
David Shiang
Abner Shimony
Herbert Simon
Dean Keith Simonton
Edmund Sinnott
B. F. Skinner
Lee Smolin
Ray Solomonoff
Roger Sperry
John Stachel
Henry Stapp
Tom Stonier
Antoine Suarez
Leo Szilard
Max Tegmark
Teilhard de Chardin
Libb Thims
William Thomson (Kelvin)
Richard Tolman
Giulio Tononi
Peter Tse
Alan Turing
Francisco Varela
Vlatko Vedral
Mikhail Volkenstein
Heinz von Foerster
Richard von Mises
John von Neumann
Jakob von Uexküll
C. S. Unnikrishnan
C. H. Waddington
John B. Watson
Daniel Wegner
Steven Weinberg
Paul A. Weiss
Herman Weyl
John Wheeler
Wilhelm Wien
Norbert Wiener
Eugene Wigner
E. O. Wilson
Günther Witzany
Stephen Wolfram
H. Dieter Zeh
Semir Zeki
Ernst Zermelo
Wojciech Zurek
Konrad Zuse
Fritz Zwicky

Presentations

Biosemiotics
Free Will
Mental Causation
James Symposium
 

Irreversibility in Ideal, Classical, and Quantum Gases
Abstract

An ideal gas is defined as one in which the details of molecular collisions, with other molecules and with the walls of the container, can be ignored. Ideal molecules have no internal structure and no interaction with matter and fields outside the container.

We define a classical gas as one described by classical dynamics including electrodynamics. Details of collisions are considered as are interactions with external electromagnetic and gravitational fields. Classical molecules have continuous internal degrees of freedom including vibration and rotation.

A quantum gas adds electron spin, Fermi-Dirac and Bose-Einstein statistics for anti-symmetric and symmetric particles, but most importantly it treats the kinetics of collisions - particle scattering - quantum mechanically. Quantum molecules have complex discrete internal structures. We ignore relativistic effects.

Gases can be studied from three perspectives - thermodynamics, statistical mechanics, and kinetic theory (which follows the details of molecular interactions). They can also be treated classically or quantum mechanically.

Boltzmann's original (1872) formulation of the H-theorem was based on the kinetics of molecular collisions, but it contained an unjustifiable assumption (Stosszahlansatz) about the absence of correlations of molecular velocities before and after the collisions (molecular chaos) that introduced probability, perhaps inadvertently, into his calculations.

f(ri, rj, pi, pj, t) = f(ri, pi, t) f(rj, pj, t)          (1)

We will show that Boltzmann's original assumption of molecular chaos may be justified for quantum gases of particles with accessible internal energy states.

With a combination of kinetic theory and probabilistic assumptions, Boltzmann derived the famous expression that he identified with Rudolf Clausius' thermodynamic entropy.

S = klogW          (2)

Five years later, Boltzmann responded to a brief remark by his Vienna colleague Josef Loschmidt that a gas with the same molecular positions but opposite velocities should show an entropy decrease, since classical mechanics is time reversible.

Boltzmann immediately agreed with Loschmidt and speculated that perhaps one could not prove the entropy increase with a purely mechanical analysis. In its place, he gave a new defense of the H-theorem (eq.2), using only the assumption of equiprobable microstates.

The entropy of a non-equilibrium macrostate is proportional to the logarithm of the number of microstates consistent with the macrostate description. Microstates compatible with thermal equilibrium outnumber non-equilibrium microstates by many orders of magnitude. Assuming that transitions between microstates are all equally likely (essentially the ergodic hypothesis as Ehrenfest named it), non-equilibrium macrostates quickly evolve to thermal equilibrium.

Macrostates that depart from equilibrium contain information (negative entropy) that in principle can be observed and measured. This includes cases of states prepared by experimenters, including removing a barrier between unlike gases, or perfume in a bottle at time zero. In these cases, quantitatively calculable information in the initial state is completely lost at equilibrium.

Increasing entropy can be equated to decreasing information.

This is the core idea of statistical mechanics, whether the gas is ideal, classical, or quantum.

Ideal gas
For an ideal gas, for example hard spheres, Boltzmann's H-theorem has been shown to hold. Entropy will increase for arbitrary initial conditions.

However, both the reversibility objection and the recurrence objection are still valid. Given special initial conditions corresponding to the highly improbable "time-reversed" velocities, the entropy will decrease.

Pierre-Simon Laplace had postulated a super intelligence who can predict the future, given perfect knowledge of the positions and velocities of material particles together with their force laws. But given the essential impossibility of preparing an initial state for a test of this or Loschmidt's hypothesis, Boltzmann thought it not a practical objection.

Extreme sensitivity to initial conditions was appreciated by James Clerk Maxwell as early as 1865 [ref?], when he noted the occurrence of singular points in hydrodynamical flows and argued that something like them in the mind might allow living creatures to escape from strict determinism. Modern computer simulations of ideal gases confirm Maxwell's and Boltzmann's intuitions, showing that miniscule errors in original positions lead very quickly to randomness in the distributions.

"Chaos theory" is the deterministic mathematical formalism that describes the dynamics of physical systems near singular points in their motions where infinitesimal differences in position or velocity lead to exponentially large differences at later times. It does not involve quantum uncertainty.

Zermelo's recurrence objection was based on Poincare's studies of the n-body problem, which indicated that recurrence would be "quasi-periodic." Poincare also discovered exceptional non-recurrent paths, which have been shown to be infinite in number yet with zero probability, a "set of measure zero" in modern terminology 1.

Conclusions for an Ideal Gas
  • Boltzmann's H-theorem is valid
  • Loschmidt's reversibility objection is valid
  • Zermelo's recurrence objection is valid

Classical gas

Boltzmann was as aware of the ideal gas approximations as any modern scientist. He was the first to include external forces (a gravitational field). He attempted kinetic calculations for polyatomic molecules. And he knew that collisions with real container walls are likely to be inelastic and non-specular, adding randomness to the time evolution of the gas.

Boltzmann also knew that the exactness of deterministic laws of classical mechanics themselves went "beyond experience." No observational evidence justified their perfection. Newton himself doubted analytical perfection, in part for theological reasons that such perfection limited God's powers.

Loschmidt's reversibility objection forced Boltzmann to see that some configurations of position and velocity might lead to to a reduction in entropy, but Boltzmann appreciated the practical impossibility of preparing such a state. He thought fluctuations of local reductions in the entropy would occur. But he argued they would be short-lived in a non-ideal gas, given the effects of random perturbations from external forces.

In modern times, calculations have shown that even tiny amounts of matter at stellar distances can alter the trajectories of classical particles. A gram of matter at the distance of Sirius can cause a particle to miss a predicted collision after as few as 50 collisions. [Berry?]

Faced with Zermelo's recurrence objection, Boltzmann calculated the recurrence time for even a small number of particles and showed that it exceeded by many orders of magnitude the likely age of the universe. For all practical purposes, recurrence to a prepared state (with all particles in half the container volume for example) was impossible.

Conclusions for a Classical Gas
  • Boltzmann's H-theorem is valid
  • Loschmidt's reversibility objection still has some merit. But not only the gas particle velocities need to be reversed, all the events in the universe must reverse, including the cosmic expansion. This ties the arrow of time to both thermodynamics and the universe expansion.
  • Zermelo's recurrence objection remains valid
Quantum gas

Just as Hamilton's classical equations of motion are time reversible, Erwin Schrodinger's reformulation of them as the equation of motion for the probability amplitude ψ(r, t) of a quantum state is time reversible. If H is the Hamiltonian,

ih/ δψ(r, t)/δτ   =   Ηψ(r, t).          (3)

Quantum statistical mechanics embodies the equiprobability assumptions about phase-space volumes (the ergodic hypothesis in both Boltzmann and Gibbs formulations) into the Fermi Golden Rule and Master Equation, which says that transition probabilities from microstate i to microstate j are equal to the reverse transition from j to i. The matrix element Pij is the complex conjugate of Pji.

Quantum kinetic theory treats the collisions of gas molecules as problems in quantum scattering. In this case, inelastic collisions could include Raman scattering that changes the internal quantum states of the colliding molecules. Moreover, colliding atoms could combine to form molecules, emitting the binding energy as radiation.

In these cases, the resulting dissociation at a later time, however short, would mean that information has been created and destroyed. As a consequence, the kind of quantum coherence needed for time reversibility of the Schrodinger equation is lost. Boltzmann's original guess that velocities of particles after collisions are random would be justified.

Conclusions for a Quantum Gas
  • Boltzmann's H-theorem is valid, a consequence of Fermi's Golden Rule (equality of forward and reverse transition probabilities between microstates) and the Master Equation.
  • Loschmidt's reversibility objection is not valid. Time reversal of the Schrodinger equation for many particles requires perfect coherence of the probability amplitudes. "Time reversibility" is irrelevant in systems that create and destroy information and thus destroy coherence.
  • Zermelo's recurrence objection is valid but does not have even quasi-periodicity. In quantum mechanics, the probability of recurrence has nothing to do with kinetic theory. It is simply the statistical mechanical probability of the initial macrostate.
Final Conclusions
Deterministic chaos for a classical gas and the assumption of equal probabilities for forward and reverse transitions between microstates (Fermi's Golden Rule) for a quantum gas are more than adequate to account for entropy increase and irreversibility in the normal time scales of terrestrial physics.

But the addition of molecular collisions analyzed as quantum scattering processes that create and destroy information, with temporary and local entropy decreases (fluctuations), strengthens the H-theorem by vitiating Loschmidt's reversibility objection. In addition, it replaces Zermelo's recurrence objection with the unavoidable but essentially vanishingly small probability that any prepared system should return to its initial conditions after a finite and physically significant time.


For Teachers
For Scholars
Notes:

1. Brush, Stephen, Kinetic Theory of Gases, vol.2, Irreversible Processes, Pergamon, Oxford, 1966. p.17

 

Normal | Teacher | Scholar